BREAKING: I-65 Serial Killer Case Solved

How To Settle An Estate Without A Will

April 21, 2022

Harry Edward Greenwell: Timeline of Crimes

April 8, 2022

Damion Moore

His reign of terror started no less than 35 years in the past in Elizabethtown, Kentucky, with the brutal homicide of Vicki Heath. Then got here the notorious “Days Inn Murders”, the horrific murders of Margaret Mary “Peggy” Gill and Jeanne Gilbert on the identical darkish and chilly Indiana night time. Legislation enforcement officers say it might take “weeks or months” earlier than a press convention.

“We’re working in the direction of a multi-agency launch and anticipate it being accessible someday within the the following few weeks [months]”

Detective Chris Denham, Elizabethtown Police Division

*The Kenneth H. O’Deen Composite sketch of the I-65 Serial Killer*

I-65 Serial Killer Recognized, however Deceased

American Crime Journal has been capable of verify by way of a number of sources, that the person we’ve referred to as the I-65 Serial Killer, often known as the perpetrator of the “Days Inn Murders” has been recognized and is deceased.

Whereas this brings the households and victims some type of closure, his closing act was that of cowardice- robbing them of some semblance of justice.

ACJ has confirmed with members of the family and buddies of the victims, nonetheless, all have declined to go on file right now. Two sources near the investigation have gone into a few of the specifics, nonetheless, these particulars haven’t been made public but. Since now we have not been capable of independently confirm them, they want to stay confidential. All confirmed they had been suggested by detectives that the killer is useless.

ACJ and our associate Sculch Studios have reached out to these legislation enforcement companies concerned within the I-65 Serial Killer investigation, together with the Indiana State Police (ISP) Lowell District which has been the lead company in Indiana because the inception of the duty drive. Additionally, we’ve spoke with the Elizabethtown Police Division which has been productive of their investigation into the homicide of Vicki Heath.

Each Elizabethtown Police Division and Indiana State Police have acknowledged {that a} press launch is coming within the subsequent few weeks (presumably months). The opposite companies have declined to go on file or remark, with the Indiana companies referring to the ISP, although one other detective confirmed that the suspected killer is deceased.

One member of the family and a former detective have expressed concern over the delayed response.

We’ll replace as new developments and particulars emerge.

Background

*From Left to proper: Peggy Gill, Jeanne Gilbert and Vicki Heath*

The I-65 Serial Killer’s reign of terror started no less than 35 years in the past, within the early morning hours of Saturday, February 21, 1987. He emerged from the darkness and entered the Tremendous 8 Motel at 2028 N. Mulberry St. simply off I-65 in Elizabethtown, Kentucky. At 6:38 a.m., a visitor went to take a look at to search out the foyer turned the wrong way up. Objects from the entrance desk was everywhere in the flooring. Furnishings was overturned, and a payphone had been ripped from the wall. Worse, the night time clerk was nowhere to be discovered. A short while later officers arrived and searched the premises. Behind the dumpster Vicki Heath was found brutally murdered. She had been sexually assaulted and executed with a .38 caliber pistol.

Within the mild dusting of snow there was a set of footprints that led to a car, that melted with the dawn. Identical to that, he vanished and not using a hint.

Heath’s homicide was believed to presumably be “a theft gone fallacious, as a result of she had put up a combat”. One hell of a combat, certainly. Officers that arrived on the scene believed a significant brawl between two teams of individuals had taken place within the lodge foyer.

By 2010, EPD detectives had not dominated out “a criminal offense of ardour” both.

The brutal homicide of Vicki Heath rocked Elizabethtown and Hardin County, however it was the Days Inn Murders on March 3, 1989, that briefly introduced this killer to the nationwide forefront.

The I-65 Serial Killer appeared out of the darkness once more. This time on the Days Inn in Merrillville, Indiana, proper off Interstate 65. He pried open the money drawer and took $179. He then took Peggy Gill, the night time auditor to an unoccupied hallway of the lodge. She was then sexually assaulted and shot to demise with a .22.

The killer then drove 52 miles south on I-65 to the Days Inn in Remington, Indiana. Inside, he pried open the money drawer and stole the $247 inside. He then kidnapped Jeanne Gilbert, the night time auditor from the lodge.

Her nude physique was discovered 19 miles away in ditch on a rural highway in White County, close to Brookston.

Like Peggy Gill, she had been sexually assaulted and executed with a .22.

Then, within the early morning hours of January 2, 1990, the I-65 Serial Killer would once more seem at a Days Inn proper off Interstate 65. This time in Columbus, Indiana. A “stereotypical wanting blue-collar trucker” walked in by way of the entrance door of the foyer and requested for change for the cigarette machine. Then requested the night time auditor if anywhere was open for breakfast. He returned fifteen to twenty minutes later with a Styrofoam cup of steaming sizzling espresso. He threw the steaming espresso within the clerk’s face and hopped the counter. As she screamed, he lined her mouth and demanding cooperation. He rapidly obtained the contents of the money drawer. His focus was then on her. He robbed her of her jewellery. In lower than a second, he was throughout her earlier than she may course of what occurred. He would then lead the clerk to a vestibule on the south finish of the lodge. The person sexually assaulted her and have become more and more hostile.

The killer led her out of the lodge and into the car parking zone. He informed her to not look again.

She survived.

DNA, nonetheless in its infancy linked the Days Inn Murders with the Columbus Assault.

The weird murders rocked the state of Indiana, Chicagoland space and past. The case gained a lot notoriety, Unsolved Mysteries started manufacturing at one level, however was all of the sudden ceased for unknown causes.

After years of being shuffled round between quite a few detectives, Elizabethtown Police Division Detective Clinton Turner submitted what little DNA proof they needed to the Kentucky State Police Crime Lab for DNA comparability in 2010.

Then in April of 2010, there was a success in Mixed DNA Index System (CODIS). It matched the DNA of an unknown offender related to the March 3, 1989, sexual assault and murders of Days Inn clerks Peggy Gill and Jeanne G i lbert, and the sexual assault the Days Inn clerk who survived an attack in Columbus 1990.

In March of 2013, Elizabethtown Police Chief Ruben Gardner (who was the lead investigator at one time) stated there was one other hit in CODIS matching a pattern collected from a victim of sexual assault and attempted murder in Rochester, Minnesota in 1991, to the unknown offender samples collected from the murders of Vicki Heath, Peggy Gill, Jeanne Gilbert and the earlier CODIS match in 2010, the Columbus sexual assault victim of 1990.

In accordance with Chief Gardner and the media sources listed under:

“In 1991, a girl in Minnesota who was additionally sexually assaulted and stabbed gave police the same description of her attacker. The sufferer described the suspect as a white male, 6′- 6’2”, inexperienced eyes, the appropriate eye was described as a lazy eye, and he had grayish brown hair. He was sporting a flannel shirt and blue denims”.

For many years, it was often called ‘The Days Inn Murders”, half spree killer and half serial rapist- if not killer by textbook definitions.

A Multi-jurisdictional and Timeline Mess

Understanding the case from legislation enforcement’s and finally the general public’s perspective is essential for this replace. The I-65 Killer begins with the Days Inn Murders. This was a time and period in legislation enforcement that interagency cooperation, databases and transparency was few and much between. The murders of Peggy Gill and Jeanne Gilbert spanned six companies alone. For these maintaining observe, Merrillville PD, Indiana State Police, Jasper County Sheriff’s Workplace, Lake County Sheriff’s Division, White County Sheriff’s Division and the Federal Bureau of Investigation.

This was adopted by the Columbus Assault 9 months later in 1990. It added two extra companies into the fray, each Columbus Police Division and Bartholomew County Sheriff’s Division.

A Activity Power was rapidly assembled, with the Indiana State Police Lowell District taking the lead.

The case was baffling as this killer may very well be seen as a serial, spree, rampage killer, theft first motive or sexually assault motivated. He killed with no cool off interval, each attacked and killed after a cool off interval, made positive he robbed the clerks, but in some way the extent of violence decreased.

The ultimate recognized victims survived the I-65 Serial Killer.

There have been additionally two different theft homicides of lodge clerks’ months earlier than the Days Inn murders. Lois “Evelyn” Wright of Rockford, Il, and James Matthew Walton of Florence, Kentucky, had been murdered simply two weeks aside in December 1988. Neither murder has been solved, and the homicide weapon a .44 magnum revolver has by no means surfaced once more in a capturing or been recovered. The Wright and Walton murders had been linked by way of ballistics recovered on the scene. The suspect made off with hundreds of {dollars} within the theft and homicide of Evelyn Wright. Rockford, Illinois, is simply two hours from Merrillville. Florence, Kentucky, is simply two hours from Elizabethtown, Kentucky, however it’s additionally one hour and forty-five minutes from Columbus, Indiana.

The time of the theft matches throughout the board- as all had been in early morning hours. Even a composite sketch of a suspicious particular person on the Walton homicide, resembles the 2 survivor’s composites of the I-65 Serial Killer. It’s unclear if they’re linked. It is extremely attainable {that a} determined robber and killer was working throughout the identical area of a serial killer, each focusing on lodge clerks.

It’s additionally vital to notice that the murder of Victoria Harshman sophisticated issues, and that homicide has its personal issues, nonetheless, her homicide has been dominated out of the I-65 Killer. The truth is, there are two suspects which have lately materialized.

Extra query than solutions

Proper now, there are extra questions than solutions. An important factor is {that a} harmful killer is off the road and that the households and victims get some sort of closure.

After all, there’s a lot to unpack from the police statements, resembling “we’re in actual fact concerned on this investigation which spans a number of companies and jurisdictions. We’re working towards a multi-agency launch and anticipate it being accessible within the subsequent few weeks [months]”.

(Through electronic mail Det. Denham initially acknowledged months, however acknowledged that the multi-agency press convention would “be in a number of weeks” throughout a clarification name with ACJ’s Jenn)

We’ll replace as new developments and particulars emerge.